A Florida couple is taking legal action against a construction company, alleging significant building code violations and construction defects in their newly built home. Patrick and Kristen Smith filed the complaint on February 25, 2025, in the Circuit Court of the Sixth Judicial Circuit in Pinellas County, Florida, against Sterling Ridge Properties Incorporated.
The lawsuit details a series of alleged construction failures by Sterling Ridge Properties, which served as the general contractor for the Smiths' home located at 484 Harbor Drive N., Indian Rocks Beach. According to the plaintiffs, the home was designed and constructed with multiple deficiencies that violate the Florida Building Code (FBC). The Smiths claim that these defects have led to severe water intrusion issues and structural problems throughout their property. They allege that Sterling Ridge Properties failed to supervise adequately and ensure compliance with building standards during construction. The plaintiffs state that "Defendant’s work in constructing and designing the Home was materially and substantially defective," pointing out specific issues such as improper flashing leading to water intrusion, inadequate waterproofing of tile decking, and incorrectly installed bathroom showers without proper drainage systems.
Patrick and Kristen Smith are seeking damages exceeding $50,001 due to these alleged violations. They assert that Sterling Ridge Properties breached its statutory duty under section 553.84 of the Florida Statutes by failing to adhere to local, state, and national building codes. The complaint highlights several sections of the FBC that were purportedly violated, including requirements for water resistance in exterior walls (R703.1.1) and proper installation of flashing (R703.4). Additionally, they accuse Sterling Ridge Properties of negligence through vicarious liability for subcontractors' work product that did not meet industry standards or code compliance.
The plaintiffs are requesting a jury trial and are asking for final judgment against Sterling Ridge Properties for damages along with interest and costs associated with rectifying these construction defects. They emphasize that these issues have significantly reduced their home's value and necessitate extensive repairs.
Representing Patrick and Kristen Smith are attorneys Alan P. Gustafson Jr., Daniel E. Kennell from Herman & Wells P.A., based in Pinellas Park, Florida. The case is presided over by Judge Ken Burke under Case Number 25-000878-CI.