Florida Record

Thursday, April 2, 2020

Nine Florida Supreme Court finalists named

Attorneys & Judges

By Michael Carroll | Jan 27, 2020

Gov. Ron DeSantis will have 60 days to choose two new justices.

TALLAHASSEE – The process to fill two vacant Florida Supreme Court seats nears the finish line as a nominating panel released a list of nine finalists headed for Gov. Ron DeSantis’ desk.

The Supreme Court Judicial Nominating Commission certified the list of finalists recently. The governor will have 60 days to choose two justices from that list to fill seats on the high court previously occupied by Barbara Lagoa and Robert Luck, who were appointed to serve on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit.

Daniel Norby, who chairs the nominating commission, said in an email to the Florida Record that the panel’s rules would likely not permit him to comment on specific nominees or the panel’s decision-making process.

“Justices Lagoa and Luck set a high bar during their short time on the Florida Supreme Court,” Norby said. “I have complete confidence in Gov. DeSantis as he decides how best to fill their vacancies from this talented list of nominees.”

Those on the list are John Couriel, an attorney with Kobre & Kim LLP; Renatha Francis, a circuit judge in Palm Beach; Judge Jonathan Gerber of the Fourth District Court of Appeal; Judge Jamie Grosshans of the Fifth District Court of Appeal; Judge Norma Lindsey of the Third District Court of Appeal; Judge Timothy Osterhaus of the First District Court of Appeal; Eliot Pedrosa, a Miami attorney who served as executive director of the InterAmerican Development Bank; Lori Rowe, a justice on the First District Court of Appeal; and Meredith Sasso, a justice on Fifth District Court of Appeal.

Couriel, Gerber, Grosshans and Osterhouse were on the finalist list last year, when DeSantis filled three vacancies on the high court.

And three of the finalists – Couriel, Lindsey and Pedrosa –  are residents of the Third Appellate District, which consists of Miami-Dade and Monroe counties. One of the appointees is required to be a resident of that district.

Kyleen Hinkle, president of the Florida Association for Women Lawyers (FAWL), reacted positively to the list of finalists.

“FAWL is pleased to see that over half the nominees from the JNC are women," Hinkle said in a prepared statement. "The Supreme Court of Florida currently has no women justices and has only ever had four. With these two appointments, Gov. DeSantis has the opportunity to change the ratio and we hope he takes it.”

The panel did not provide the maximum number of finalists that it could have sent, according to judicial nominating rules. The commission could have sent the governor a list of 12, or six per open seat. 

A total of 32 people were interviewed by the judicial nominating committee prior to the announcement of finalists this week.

The only African American on the list is Francis. Some observers have called on the governor to appoint an African American justice since no blacks currently serve as justices of the high court.

Want to get notified whenever we write about Florida Supreme Court ?

Sign-up Next time we write about Florida Supreme Court, we'll email you a link to the story. You may edit your settings or unsubscribe at any time.

Organizations in this Story

Florida Supreme Court

More News